×

HOW TO SHOP

1 Login or create new account.
2 Review your order.
3 Payment & FREE shipment

If you still have problems, please let us know, by sending an email to support@website.com . Thank you!

SHOWROOM HOURS

Mon-Fri 9:00AM - 6:00AM
Sat - 9:00AM-5:00PM
Sundays by appointment only!

SIGN IN YOUR ACCOUNT TO HAVE ACCESS TO DIFFERENT FEATURES

FORGOT YOUR PASSWORD?

FORGOT YOUR DETAILS?

AAH, WAIT, I REMEMBER NOW!
QUESTIONS? CALL: 0800 3000 11

Coachio Group NZCoachio Group NZ

  • MY CART
    No products in cart.
  • Homepage
  • About Us
    • The Coachio Team
    • Info Pack
    • Gallery
    • Careers
  • Training
    • Adult Education
      • Adult Learning – Physical Skills
      • Adult Learning – Mental Skills
      • Train the Trainer
    • Business
      • Administrative Skills
        • Administrative Office Procedures
        • Administrative Support
        • Archiving and Records Management
        • Basic Bookkeeping
        • Business Writing
        • The Cloud and Business
        • Collaborative Business Writing
        • Meeting Management
        • Organisational Skills
        • Social Media in the Workplace
        • Supply Chain Management
      • Business Confidence
        • Communication Strategies
        • Contract Management
        • Crisis Management
        • Developing Creativity
        • Digital Citizenship
        • Entrepreneurship
        • Interpersonal Skills
        • Negotiation Skills
        • Personal Branding
        • Ten Soft Skills You Need
        • Time Management
        • Women in Leadership
      • Continuous Improvement
        • Creative Problem Solving
      • Human Resources
        • Business Succession Planning
        • Developing a “Lunch & Learn”
        • Employee Onboarding
        • Employee Recruitment
        • Employee Termination Process
        • Generation Gaps
        • Hiring Strategies
        • Human Resource Management
        • Measuring Results from Training
        • Millennial Onboarding
      • Leadership
        • NZ Certificate in Business (Level 3)
        • NZ Certificate in Business (Level 4)
      • Personal Development
      • Sales and Marketing
      • Workplace Essentials
        • Amazing Customer Experience
    • Health, Safety & Wellbeing
      • Health & Safety Advisor Development Program
      • Health & Safety Representatives
        • Health & Safety Reps Training
        • Health & Safety Representative Development Program
      • ICAM – Incident Cause Analysis Method
      • MICAM – Maximised Incident Cause Analysis Method
      • The Art of the Investigation
      • Operational Risk
      • NEBOSH
        • Award in Health and Safety at Work
        • Award in Safety, Health and Environment for the Process Industries
        • Certificate in Environmental Management
        • Environmental Diploma
        • International Construction Certificate
        • International Diploma FULL E-learning
        • International Fire Certificate
        • International General Certificate
        • International Oil and Gas Certificate
      • IOSH
        • IOSH Managing Safely
        • IOSH Working Safely
      • IEMA
        • Foundation Certificate in Environmental Management
        • Associate Certificate in Environmental Management
    • Project Management
      • Project Management
  • Coachio Consulting
    • Business Improvement
    • HR & Leadership
    • Health, Safety & Risk
    • Audit & Investigation
  • Promotion
  • Contact Us
  • Latest News
  • Orders
FREE WHITEPAPERS
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Leadership
  • The Leadership Paradox
January 17, 2021

The Leadership Paradox

The Leadership Paradox

by Ian Ashworth / Tuesday, 27 October 2020 / Published in Leadership

We don’t want great leadership.

That sentence alone might be enough to convince you that I’m talking nonsense. Whilst you can probably find plenty of evidence to back that up, on this occasion – the occasion where I lead with probably the most preposterous, attention seeking, confrontational statement I’ve put my name to – I’ll try to convince you I’m not. Or, at least, there’s some thinking behind the words.

We all say we want great leadership and, on an individual basis, that’s undoubtedly true. We hear about great leaders and look longingly in their direction, wishing we had greater insight into their minds, or even worked in their presence. We read books about leadership by people who have studied it for years, experiencing our own “a-ha” moments as we lap them up. We certainly love a good leadership quote, if social media meme likes are anything to go by.

So why, then, given our desire for everything great leadership has to offer, are there such mixed results and inconsistency when it comes to companies having great leaders? Sure, not everyone can be great at everything, and there’s no one definition of “Great Leadership”, and therefore no set right way of doing it. But with enough material on the subject, enough role models out there, we should all be pointed in roughly the right direction.

The devil is in the detail. Three significant things happen that prove to me that we don’t value leadership highly enough, despite what we say.

The first is around promotions. Many of us are lucky enough to have a team of excellent people around us; subject matter experts and technical masters at what they do. So what do you do when they reach their ceiling in that role? Promote them to people leadership positions to justify throwing a bit more money at them to keep them happy and, largely, hope they make it.

What’s often the end result? No longer are they experts, and the reality that they now have to manage and lead people, a skill set entirely different from what they’d previously excelled with, scares the living daylights out of them. It’s little wonder that they revert to what they know and stick to being experts, and the leadership part becomes an avoided chore. Before long, and more damaging to a wider number of people, their team is done a disservice through poor leadership. Sinking or swimming is treacherous enough when you’re risking one person, when it’s a capsized boat, it’s a lot more difficult to haul that many people out of the water.

If we truly wanted great leadership, we would set people on that path from a much earlier point. It should be part of that person’s development plan; their career pathway, but only if that’s something they’re interested in. It’s not for everyone. For those people, we must help them grow in other ways within and beyond their existing roles. They’re still leaders. We owe it to our outstanding people to give them the best chance to succeed and not leave it to luck.

The second thing that makes me question our desire for great leadership is recruitment. We’ve all seen the job ads. “Widget Manager, great organisation, we want a great leader, great opportunity etc.” Scan down the ad to the bullet points of essential skills. First one, “Must have 10+ years experience making widgets”, somewhere on the sixth or seventh bullet point, after the one about the ability to meet widget targets, and the one about having a degree in widget making, comes “Leadership experience”.

I’m in the camp that believes that most manager roles are 80% leadership, 20% technical knowledge. Yet that 20% seems to be driving our leadership positions, with experience leading people relegated to an afterthought. Check out Seek or your local recruitment agency ads; they’ll all be pretty much the same. This isn’t necessarily a knock on the agencies doing the recruitment, it’s the demands of their clients to value technical experience over leadership skills.

Finally, the third detail that gets in the way of great leadership is a part of the recruitment process; the interview. Most companies of any size recruit with two or more people on the interview panel, preferably with one HR person, or at least someone independent from another area. They’re there largely to assess cultural fit, and look beyond the technical expertise of the applicant. Why, then, don’t we take enough notice of those other people on the panel when they provide valuable input? I have all too often seen their views rank lower in importance to the hiring manager who is almost predetermined in their requirements. Yes, the hiring manager is the one accountable at the end of the day and will have the person reporting directly to them, but there’s more to all roles, not just leadership ones, than skills in the area they’re going to be working in. I’m not advocating for ignoring those skills and only recruiting people who “fit in” but, ultimately, you can often teach skills much easier than you can make a square peg fit in a round hole.

No one actively wants bad leadership but, until we make significant changes in these three areas, until we stop pushing it down our list of priorities, I’ll remain convinced that the desire to have great leadership is little more than a nice meme and the source of, ironically, yet another article.

At Coachio, we don’t just write messages on boards, we believe in them and we know we can help. We can deliver anything from training for new or aspiring leaders, to management training, through to exec coaching, and customise programmes to be specifically relevant to your needs. Contact us to find out more.

0
  • Tweet

About Ian Ashworth

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Christmas Shutdown

    At Coachio, we’re taking a Christmas brea...
  • Special Offers

    We know December and January can often mean one...
  • Risk Doesn’t Have To Be Risky

    There’s an increasing tendency to view risk tak...
  • Coachio Office News – August 2020

    We’ve recently welcomed two new members t...
  • Is your business delivering exceptional customer service?

    At Coachio Group, when we work with clients to ...

Recent Comments

  • Risk Doesn’t Have To Be Risky – Coachio Group NZ on Health & Safety Representatives
  • Martin Mckenzie on NEBOSH Certificate in Process Safety Management

Archives

  • December 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • August 2017
  • May 2017
  • January 2017
  • September 2016
  • August 2016

Categories

  • Audits
  • Coachio meet Simon Sinek
  • Customer service
  • Health & Safety
  • Leadership
  • News
  • Risk
  • Training
  • Uncategorized
  • Updates

Featured Posts

  • Christmas Shutdown

    0 comments
  • Special Offers

    0 comments
  • Risk Doesn’t Have To Be Risky

    0 comments
  • Coachio Office News – August 2020

    0 comments
  • Is your business delivering exceptional customer service?

    0 comments

QUICK LINKS

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • News
  • Consulting
  • Training
  • Coachio Online Courses
  • Register/Login

COACHIO CORNER NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By subscribing to our mailing list you will always be updated with the latest news from us.

We never spam!

GET IN TOUCH

Phone NZ : 0800 3000 11 or 022 184 4689

Email: info@coachiogroup.com

Coachio Group Ltd
Head Office
Level 2, South British House
35 Grey Street
Tauranga 3110, New Zealand

Open in Google Maps

30 days agoAs is the case for most organisations, 2020 has been a very unique year for Coachio Group Limited and the team dese… https://t.co/Vm0GJ9ycCZ
41 days agoA great opportunity to invest in both people and technology! https://t.co/OlEfVS0VAY
45 days agoYou know you're surrounded by great people when they're willing to interrupt their busy day to work together and he… https://t.co/rcDmPYmBhV
Follow @@CoachioCom
social sharing
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • News
  • Consulting
  • Training
  • Coachio Online Courses
  • Register/Login
  • GET SOCIAL

© 2020 All rights reserved. The Coachio Group.

TOP